There's a famous video of a guy dancing alone at a festival. For several painful seconds, he looks like a lunatic. Then one person joins him. Within minutes, a crowd surrounds them. That moment—when the second person steps in—transforms everything. The lone nut becomes a leader. And the first follower? They become the real architect of what follows.
This is the first follower principle, and it explains why some founders struggle for years while others attract believers almost instantly. The difference isn't product quality or charisma. It's understanding what first followers actually want.
They're Not Betting on You
Here's the counterintuitive truth: your first follower isn't investing in your vision. They're investing in what your success would mean for them.
When Infusionsoft launched in 2004, early customers weren't buying marketing automation software. They were buying the identity of being "real marketers" in a world where competitors still relied on sticky notes. The gap between who they were (guy with a spreadsheet) and who they wanted to become (serious marketer with automation) drove the buying decision more than any feature.
The same psychology applies to every type of first follower. An investor who commits early isn't evaluating your pitch deck; they're imagining the story they'll tell about discovering you. An employee who joins pre-traction isn't following a leader; they're claiming a role in a narrative they want for themselves.
The Two Paths That Don't Work
Founders typically try one of two approaches to attract followers. Neither works.
The first is what you might call the Forrest Gump approach: be so undeniably visionary that people simply materialize. Just start running across America and believers will appear. This fantasy rarely survives contact with reality.
The second approach is purely tactical: study your market, design your messaging to appeal to them, manufacture the movement. This fails differently. People can smell calculation. Nobody wants to be the first follower of a manufactured vision.
The founders who actually attract first followers operate in the tension between these poles. They have an authentic vision they'd pursue regardless of who follows, but they communicate it in ways that let the right people see themselves in it.
What Makes You Followable
The dancing video reveals the mechanics. The leader's moves are simple, almost instructional. Complex choreography would exclude potential followers. When the first person joins, the leader embraces them as an equal. It stops being about the leader and becomes about them, plural.
First followers need to answer immediately, without words: what is this thing I'm following? If you're pursuing ten directions at once, nobody follows. A movement requires one thing so easy to comprehend that a follower could explain it to a friend in a sentence.
The Agile Manifesto became a massive movement without anyone knowing who wrote it. The idea was clear enough that first followers could propagate it without needing the founders present. That's the real test of followability.
Authenticity Isn't Optional
There's a documentary about the Liver King, a fitness influencer who built an enormous following around an ancestral lifestyle persona. When his private use of performance-enhancing drugs surfaced, everything collapsed. He'd created a character rather than being who he actually was.
Every founder knows they're flawed. Many avoid being front-and-center precisely because they fear their flaws will surface. But the solution isn't hiding behind a manufactured persona. It's showing up authentically while being clear about what you're building.
Vulnerability creates more durable followings than false confidence. When you talk openly about failures alongside successes, first followers trust you more, not less. They're not following perfection; they're following someone who's figured out something they haven't.
The Identity Upgrade
Stop looking for people who believe in your vision. Start looking for people who desperately want the identity upgrade your success would give them. Frame your vision so they see their own future in your success.
When you get this right, you stop being a lone nut dancing by yourself. You become the leader of something real.
Watch the Full Episode on the First Follower Principle below:
Follow us to watch live on YouTube and LinkedIn or listen to episodes on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.