Why do some founders get replies from total strangers while your emails get ignored?
Research from Boomerang analyzed five million emails and found messages between fifty and one hundred twenty-five words get the highest response rates. Yet most founders either write novels or fire off three-sentence pitches. When one founder launched his SaaS product, he built his early customer base through cold email by spending thirty minutes researching each recipient before writing a single word. That investment in understanding inbox psychology turned strangers into allies who wanted to help.
The shift starts before you write anything: believe people want to help. Not everyone, but enough. About fifty-five percent of emails are spam, which means you're competing for attention in a crowded inbox. Standing out requires building trust before you ask for anything.
Cold outreach isn't a single action—it's a sequence. Think of it as moving someone through three stages: they need to know you exist, like what they see, and trust you enough to engage. To get on someone's radar, send a connection request with no ask. Comment on their post with a genuine observation. These micro-touches signal you're paying attention without demanding attention.
When they check your profile, what do they see? A professional photo. A track record with recognizable companies. A clear value proposition. If your profile looks empty, you've lost them. Trust comes from specificity—mention a mutual connection by name, reference their recent work with details only someone who paid attention would know.
Subject lines compete with a hundred other decisions happening in that moment. Generic hooks fail because they sound like every other pitch. Start with their name. Follow with something specific: "Introduction to sports startups" or "Question about your podcast episode." The specificity signals this isn't mass-sent. When a reporter received "Introduction to basketball startups" during NBA All-Star weekend, seven out of thirty replied. Two wrote articles.
Inside the email, structure matters more than length. Every cold message needs four elements in this order:
First line: The connection point. Give a specific compliment about their recent work, or name-drop a mutual contact. "I really enjoyed your episode on cold calls and learned how to frame requests as value" beats "I like your profile."
Second line: What you want. Don't bury it. "I'm approaching you because I'd like your advice on working with startups in Colorado." Clarity respects their time.
Third line: Why they should care. Build credibility fast. "I've been helping startups generate revenue for fifteen years, working with companies like X and Y." Name-dropping works here if the names carry weight.
Fourth line: The ask. End with a question mark, not a period. Research shows questions increase response rates by twenty percent because our brains see question marks as prompts requiring answers. "Can I send you more information?" or "Can we schedule a thirty-minute call?"
This structure forces clarity and makes the recipient's decision simple: yes or no.
Certain patterns guarantee your email gets ignored. Starting with "In today's world" or "The startup landscape is chaotic" triggers instant spam filters in people's brains. Copy-pasting the same message to everyone shows. Asking for too much too soon forces an immediate no. Start smaller—ask for advice, a short call, or permission to send more information.
Cold outreach works when you stop treating it like broadcasting and start treating it like building relationships at compressed speed. The founders who get responses aren't luckier or more connected—they're more deliberate. They warm the relationship before asking, structure messages for clarity, and make it easy to say yes.
Watch the Full Episode on Cold Email Strategies with expert Lirone Glickman below:
Follow us to watch live on YouTube and LinkedIn or listen to episodes on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.